Wolf

says to stay close to the animatronics. There is no way he didn't know what was going on with the animatronics. So this, to me, puts him as one of the causes of the Bite incident. He is keeping info from us, he obviously feels guilty of something since he puts himself in position to be murdered but it can't be the bite sicne that hasn't happened, so what is the story with Phone Guy?
I feel like The Puppet and the Originals are the only haunted animatronics. The others could very well have just been messed with as suggested. But who messed with them? Is their a third party we've yet to hear from, this Purple Man, or is the true culprit hiding in plain sight? A suspect was arrested, but we don't know if they were truly the killer.
Another thing though; I don't think the guard mentioned on Night 1 is our killer. He complained about The Puppet trying to break in. If this Purple Man is our kliller, The Puppet (as seen in the SAVETHEM minigame) ignores the Purple Man. So what connection does our Purple Man have to The Puppet, other than potentially have created it? Why does it ignore him?
So that's pretty much all I've got for FNaF2. If I discover or think of anything else I will let you know. Feel free to comment, correct me, or ask questions.

View more

From what we know from FNaF, two children went missing in June. We have no indication when the other three went missing. But as of Night 4 of FNaF2 all the old animatronics are after you. So between June and Night 4 the other three went missing and were murdered. We know that the old animatronics aren't really used much because they look terrible and 'smell.' It makes sense that at least two of them would give off this odor as two children are already dead. Four of the older animatronics are capable of making appearances as early as Night 2 in FNaF2. So I honestly feel like, given the minigame clues, that the last three murders may have occured during the first three Days of the game. Two children are dead before the game begins, filling two animatronics. The third child may have been killed immediately preceeding the game, and the fourth child being killed after Night 1, filling all four of the old animatronics that can attack you. Then the fifth child is killed on Day 3. And Night 3 is when Phone Guy starts talking about the rumors surrounding the resturaunt. I don't feel like that the last three were killed prior to the game, police would have been up all over the case, and everything seems to hit the fan on Night 4.
Before I get to the last topic 'in-game' I want to mention, I want to talk about Scott. Scott has created an amazing story out of such a simple concept. The easiest way I can think to descibe FNaF is 'You're the night guard at Chuck E Cheese and he's trying to kill you.' Such a simple concept and he's crafted a well thought out story. But Scott isn't telling us everything, both literally and metaphysically. Literally in the sense he really isn't confirming anything.
Metaphysically in the sense that Scott is the voice of the Phone Guy. And to me, Phone Guy is a liar. I'm not prepared to say he's the Purple Man as Game Theory wants to say, but Phone Guy isn't being 100% honest with us. He is what I would call an unreliable narrator. Aside from things in the environment the only way this story is told is through Phone Guy. He acts like he knows more than he lets on. Listening to him in game one told me that. But in this one he really made me suspicious of him. Specifically his comment about The Puppet, he doesn't like it because 'It's always thinking.' Why would he use that expression if he doesn't honestly believe that there is anything going on with the animatronics that can't be explained by malfunctioning equipment? But what makes this even stranger, assuming he knows that they're homicidal, he says he'll take the night shift after the resturaunt reopens. He is basically committing suicide. Why? What does he know that makes him choose to go to slaughter? I also believe he caused one of the events that led to the resturaunt closing; the Bite of '87. He made note to say the animatronics were acting hostile towards staff and adults, and we're being moved to the day shift on the day we are led to believe that Bite occurs. He

View more

implies that The Puppet has a connection to the dead children. Could he be the murderer? Or do they have something in common?
The next minigame I think of is Take Cake to the Children. In this one you are Freddy in a small building and you have to give six children cake. Doing so keeps them green but leave them alone too long they turn red because they're probably unhappy. But outside this building is a crying child. During the game a purple vehicle appears as does the Purple Man I mentioned earlier. The child appears to stop crying, but cries harder when the Purple Man kills him. During the game letters are caleld out to spell out SAVEHIM. The game ends with a Puppet jumpscare. I feel that this incident occurs at FredBear's Family Diner. The building is small enough to be a diner, and the Freddy could just be an employye in a suit (which given what we already know about the suits is plausible) But why does The Puppet jumpscare you? I feel this was the first of many tragic incidents to occur with Freddy's franchise. And given that it appears that The Puppet was the first animatronic to turn homicidal, I think the murdered child in this game became The Puppet. The Puppet looks like it's crying despite it's evil looking smile, and its tears are purple. Whether that means something or is just a coincidence is speculatory.
The last minigame is a Foxy minigame. In it you control Foxy and entertain children in Pirates Cove. But not all the children look happy. You do this twice, but on the third time our purple friend appears smiling in the starting room. When you go see the children they appear to be dead. Why is our purple friend smiling? Is he happy with what he appears to have done, or is he happy to see Foxy? To me I feel like these minigames are trying to help us understand The Missing Children Incident. And possibly how this whole thing began.
The Missing Children Incident. One of two infamous events surrounding the Freddy franchise. Five children went missing and (given what we know) were probably murdered and stuffed into the original suits we encountered in game one. But we just don't know when. I think clues in this game tell us when it happens. In game one it is alleged that the murderer used a spare costume to lure the children to their demise. During Night 6 Phone Guy makes a mention that the resturaunt is shutting down and that someone used a spare suit, Golden Freddy. But he doesn't say what it was used for. The Missing Children, combined with the Bite of '87, shut this resturaunt down. (My computer is getting glitchy and I don't want to lose this again so I will use your older comments about it to continue)

View more

I did say I'd give a formal analysis. I did however decide to wauit this long to make certain as much info could be readily available to me so I could figure this out.
Let's start with the obvious issue; prequel or sequel. Even before watching The Game Theorist video I thought this was a prequel. Phone Guy mentions in 2 that the animatronics can walk around in the daytime, in the original this isn't the case due to 'previous incidents'. Also, our paycheck is dated for 1987, which is before game one if you believe that minimum wage thing. Plus, Phone Guy is alive when he should be dead. The paper clipping saying the building will be made smaller fits with our location in game 1, the lack of the animatronics from game 2 in game 1 fits as they're scrapped at the end of this one. This game seems to set up everything we know from the first game. Actually, this game seems to be right before the infamous Bite of '87 but I'll get to that in a moment.
Next; The Puppet. This thing is by far one of the creepier animatronics but if my analysis is right one of the most important. One night 1 of FNaF2 Phone Guy mentions the previous night guard had problems with an animatronic trying to break into his office because there wasn't any sound and it thought it was in the wrong room. So their solution was the music box. The Puppet is the only one soothed by this music box. This leads me to believe the animatronic problems began with The Puppet. I have more to say about The Puppet, but it'll make more sense in context.
The Death Mini-games. A new twist on the deaths of FNaF and could possibly be quite telling.
The first game that comes to mind is the SAVETHEM game. You control Freddy and are chasing what appears to be an almost ghostly visage of The Puppet. During the game the words Save Them is spelled out. There are dead bodies, Mangle, and occasionally Golden Freddy. All of which end the game. There is also a Purple Man who chases you. This purple man appears to have a spot of yellow on him as well. Now given that we're assuming this is the Pizzeria, who would have something yellow pinned to them? A security guard maybe? The Purple Man chases you and getting caught by him ends the game and flashes 'You Can't.' on the screen. The game is telling you to save them, but the Purple Man says you can't? But also, why is Freddy chasing The Puppet? Obviously the thing is evil but there has to be a better reason. I'll come back to this Purple Man in a minute.
The next one that comes to mind is Give Gifts, Give Life. In this one you control The Puppet and there are what appears to be four dead children. You're told to give them gifts, and after doing so to give life. During this when you touch the children masks of the original characters are placed on them. this further implies that the missing kids were put into the suits. It's followed by a Golden Freddy scare, but right before we see him the fifth child appears, implying Golden Freddy is the fifth child. This to me also

View more